Lexi is the next "lucky" lady to receive our massive pie barrage. Both The Man and The Wife wallop her using 30 filling filled cool whip pies. "More!" Lexi shouts in the middle of the barrage, but her voice is instantly muffled by the next pie hit. They nail her in the face over and over again without stopping until all 30 pies are all used up. After the creamy madness concludes, The Wife insists that Lexi needs some more color to go along with all those pies. Lexi says "No!" but we say yes. She's then dumped on with a boldly colored chunky blue slime. After the slime finishes covering her, she demands to know why The Wife would do that to her after she already took all those pies. However, Lexi really should be careful with what she says. As she speaks, she utters the trigger phrase, and takes a dousing of chunky green slime to finish her off.

After footage included of Lexi playing in the post scene slop on the floor. She also gets a yucky recycled sliming while The Wife watches with glee.