Leaving for a pool party with her gal pals, a bikini clad Courtney had to make a stop for some sunscreen that she mistakenly left on set. But instead of finding sunscreen, she stumbles upon the infamous raft, and it's completely filled with shaving cream. Courtney immediately thinks of the last girl to fall into the raft, who was none other than Lilly. Courtney bemoans how ridiculous Lilly was to even go near the raft in the first place and not expect anything to happen. That's right when Lilly herself sneaks up behind an unsuspecting Courtney and slaps her ass, which causes her to plummet head first into all the cream. At this point, Lilly is complete control, as she asserts her dominance over a very clumsy Courtney. Lilly shoves Courtney's head under the shaving cream over and over again, making sure to spread it all over her body as well. She also occasionally wipes Courtney's soles off so that everyone can she her bare feet. Lilly pretends to help Courtney out of the raft multiple times, only to either "accidentally" lose her grip, or straight up toss her back in it. Courtney is unable to get herself out, as she clumsily falls back into the raft on multiple escape attempts.

As if all this wasn't enough, then come the 25 pies. These pies are all very colorful and made with cool whip. The vast majority have no tin, so they completely explode as they're thrown at Courtney's face one after the next. She whines and complains, but the pies keep coming. After one final pie to Courtney's ass, Lilly takes more pleasure in picking up right where she left off. She pushes Courtney around more and forcefully dunks her face into the now extra creamy raft over and over again. Finally, Courtney's had just about enough of Lilly's shenanigans, and manages to pull her right into the raft! Courtney wastes no time exacting her revenge, dunking Lilly's face into the creamy concoction multiple times. Following the attack on Lilly, a truce is formed between the two ladies, but it doesn't last very long. Lilly thinks back through the whole ordeal, and recalls that Courtney said the trigger phrase. This causes a very large and chunky green sliming to rain down, absolutely clobbering poor Courtney. It splatters and glops all over, completely coating her in a vivid green. Lilly thinks that she had the last laugh, but she's suddenly hit with a wave of chocolate heaved from a bucket right in her face.

After footage shows these two being complete goofs in all of the cream, crust, and slime that now fill the raft.