Lilly seems to be stuck on the motto, "New Year, new you." Which is why she's brought 15 pounds of buttercream frosting to set. Because of all the messy things The Wife has experienced over the years, she's never been covered in buttercream before. Lilly starts with her arms, being sure to lift up and get under them too. She takes extra care to rub the frosting all over The Wife's chest, smothering her boobs and ruining her brand new white bra. And with a grin, Lilly coats The Wife's face and her very long hair. She makes sure to work the thick buttercream deeply in, adding more as needed. After all this, Lilly sits back and looks at her handywork, enjoying the sight of The Wife smothered in purple buttercream. Lilly thinks she's gotten away clean, but she's forgotten one simple fact... best friends think alike. After being slathered by Lilly, The Wife reveals that she too has 15 pounds of buttercream frosting, only hers is orange. A visibly bewildered Lilly has no choice but to simply accept her fate. The Wife then takes great pleasure in delivering the comeuppance that Lilly so rightly deserves. She does the exact same things to Lilly as was done to her. The Wife even devotes more time to scrub and work the heavy buttercream into Lilly's hair. When all is said and done, each buttercream buddy gets one extra messy substance: The Wife gets pied and Lilly takes an extra chunky green sliming.

After footage shows both ladies being goofy while covered in the buttercream. They also turn around to show off just how coated their hair really is.